Anyone immersed in Wisconsin food culture knows what makes up a great supper club—a relish tray, quality food, and excellent service. West Allis is home to what I would like to call an Italian supper club, Caterina’s Ristorante at 9104 W. Oaklahoma Ave.

Rolling up, the building gives off longevity and authenticity, which is exacerbated by the inside decor. You’re surrounded by wooden chairs and booth fixtures with walls that make you feel a real supper club vibe. While it was a beautiful summer night, it was lovely to be inside this establishment to feel like you’re somewhere else besides Milwaukee for a couple of hours.