Sometimes, the soul wants what the soul wants – and sometimes, what the soul wants is some delicious, incredibly authentic Italian food. I get it, which is why I’ve spent (probably way too much) time checking out some of the all-time best spots for Italian food in Indiana.

Now, get this: the best Italian food in Indiana is not necessarily found in a standalone brick-and-mortar building or a chain place. Nope! It’s nestled within a strip mall in Indianapolis: one of the best places to eat in Indiana if you’re looking for it.