Outside of Italy, New York is one of the best cities in the world to find quality Italian cuisine. Its abiding love for all things pasta and pizza have led to a history of world-class restaurants from Michelin-starred to casual authenticity with a New York edge. Picking just five restaurants is near impossible. Nevertheless, we’ve rounded up the city’s most beloved Italian hotspots.

Whether you’re looking for authentic handmade pasta, an Italian gem or a spot that is more exclusive than Soho House, here are our picks for New York’s top essential Italian restaurants to visit all year long.