Want some filling food with an atmosphere that is just as good as what’s on the plate? Looking for authentic and timeless meals that make you want to ask for seconds—or even thirds? Looking for reliable flavor from dishes that are as good today as they were many decades ago?

Then check out DeStefano’s Olde Erie, a restaurant in Middletown, New York that serves up classic Italian-American fare and more. It might just have the best Italian food in Middletown, New York. To learn more about this establishment, keep reading below.